As the
investigation into Russian influence in the 2016 election now carries into
2018, Justice Department special counsel Robert Mueller is keeping quiet on
details.
But one
thing does seem clear: A year after President Trump took office, the crime of
foreign money laundering looks as though it has become an important focus.
Or, as
former White House chief strategist Stephen Bannon told Michael Wolff in his
bestselling book, Fire and Fury, "You realize where this is going ... This
is all about money laundering."
Here's
what is known:
Among
the first Trump associates to be indicted last year was campaign manager Paul
Manafort, who is accused of laundering money by purchasing several properties
in New York and Virginia. Manafort, who has worked for pro-Kremlin officials in
Ukraine, has pleaded not guilty and is expected to stand trial later this year.
Manafort's
attorneys have pointed out the charges he is facing date from years before he
joined the Trump campaign and don't have any bearing on any alleged collusion
between the Trump team and Russians.
Mueller
has hired several prosecutors with experience in prosecuting financial crimes
such as money laundering, including Andrew Weissman, chief of the Justice
Department's criminal fraud section.
"I
don't think he (Mueller) would have brought them onto his team if that wasn't
going to be an area that would be focused on," says former federal
prosecutor Kenneth McCallion, who helped investigate ties between Trump and New
York Mafia figures in the 1980s.
Several
published reports say Mueller's team has issued subpoenas to Deutsche Bank for
records pertaining to Trump associates. Deutsche Bank was the only major
commercial bank willing to lend to Trump after his string of bankruptcies. It
has also been accused of laundering Russian money by the New York State
Department of Financial Services.
White
House attorneys have denied the reports of the subpoenas, but the bank has made
no comment one way or the other. All it has said is that it cooperates with
investigators but will not comment on individual cases.
People
familiar with big financial crime cases say the role of Trump's bank could be
critical.
"It's
important that Mr. Mueller find out what happened there, because Deutsche Bank
was known as having extensive, intensive relationships with money from former
Soviet republics generally and Russia in particular," says Jonathan Winer,
former deputy assistant Secretary of State for international law enforcement.
Deutsche
Bank has paid hundreds of millions of dollars in fines to American, British and
European regulators after admitting its role in some big financial crimes.
Trump
and his family have not been implicated and the president maintains that he has
done nothing wrong. Outside critics have maintained all along, however, that
Trump's real estate empire has been the Western terminus for a clandestine
pipeline of illicit money from the Eastern Bloc.
What Is
Money Laundering? And Why Does It Matter To Robert Mueller?
NATIONAL
SECURITY
What Is
Money Laundering? And Why Does It Matter To Robert Mueller?
Former
prosecutor McCallion said the laundering of money became a global issue for law
enforcement not long after the fall of the Soviet Union.
"Russian
money was looking to really find a home outside Russia, in Western Europe and
the United States, and real estate was one of the investments of choice,"
McCallion said.
Trump
has repeatedly denied having any business deals inside Russia, but money from
the former Soviet Union was used to finance some of his branded properties,
including the Trump Soho in New York and the Trump International Hotel and
Tower in Toronto. (Both properties have since changed their names.)
In
addition, the Trump Organization has marketed and sold numerous properties to
wealthy people from the former Soviet Union.
"In
terms of high-end product influx into the U.S., Russians make up a pretty
disproportionate cross-section of a lot of our assets, say in Dubai and
certainly with our project in Soho and anywhere in New York," Donald Trump
Jr. said in 2008.
Doing
business with people from the former Soviet Union is not illegal. But real
estate companies, like banks, are supposed to exercise "due
diligence" to make sure they're not receiving money gained through illegal
activities such as drug sales and tax evasion.
Real estate
transactions are especially difficult to trace because of the widespread use of
offshore corporations to mask the purchasers' true identities, Winer says.
None of
this means Trump or his family knowingly took illegally laundered money, but
certain transactions have raised questions about his business relationships.
Among
them was Trump's 2008 sale of a Palm Beach mansion to Russian fertilizer king
Dmitri Rybolovlev for almost $100 million, nearly twice what Trump had paid for
it four years before.
Paying
too much for properties is a classic form of laundering illegally gotten money.
Entire sections of London have been snapped up by wealthy foreign owners as
ways to park cash garnered elsewhere, but the people who buy them are never
home. So neighborhoods sit empty with no one home, a phenomenon dubbed
"Lights out London."
Critics
wonder whether Trump is one of the people who benefits on the receiving end of
a pipeline that runs to the United States — or whether he might have an even
deeper relationship with wealthy Russians.
"A
Russian tactic is to invest in individuals through overpaying, for example,
bailing people out ... or preying on individuals who are in financial
distress," says Rep. Eric Swallwell (D-Calif.)
"So
that would be an effort to try to make someone like you or somebody receptive
to you, and then hope they would act in your interest or that they would fear
that your investments in them would be revealed, and so you're in a blackmail
or extortion or compromat—as they call it—type of position," Swalwell
said.
In other
words, irrespective of what relationship Trump's campaign might have had with
the Russian attack on the 2016 election, the question becomes whether Trump
might want to frustrate Mueller's investigation because of what it might
uncover about his personal finances.
Swallwell
said he isn't suggesting that Russians might be blackmailing Trump, which has
come up before in this story. But he did say Americans deserved an answer about
what he called Trump's unwillingness to criticize Russian President Vladimir
Putin and take positions friendly to Moscow.
"He
certainly is acting in their interests, and what we want to find out is, is
there a nefarious reason for that?"